The MY Wealth Watch Retirement Newsletter

Whether you're a few years from retirement or already in it, our newsletter is built for people 50+ who want to make the most of their next chapter. Twice a month, we share financial strategies, market insights, and practical tips to help you grow and protect your wealth.

Jun 18 • 5 min read

Are You Making These 5 Portfolio Mistakes?


You’ve built a real portfolio. Maybe across a few 401(k)s from past jobs, an IRA or two, a taxable brokerage account, possibly a Roth.

It’s worked. Your statements look healthy. Why mess with it?

Because the things that hurt retirement portfolios usually aren’t dramatic. They’re quiet. They build up over years. And by the time they show up in your returns, the damage is already done.

Here are five of the most common issues we look for.

Too Many Accounts in Too Many Places

How many retirement accounts do you have right now? Count them honestly.

It’s common to have more than you realize. A 401(k) from a job you left in 2009. A rollover IRA from the one before that. A small Roth you opened and never added to. A spousal IRA somewhere.

Here’s the thing. There aren't many reasons to keep an IRA at Fidelity and another one at Schwab. The brokerage house doesn’t diversify you. Your specific investments do.

Holding similar things in different places isn’t diversification. It’s just extra complexity.

And the complexity has a cost.

When your money is scattered, it’s difficult to see it as one picture. Your asset allocation isn’t really your asset allocation. It’s whatever the accidental sum of those accounts happens to be.

Rebalancing becomes guesswork. Tax planning becomes harder. Required Minimum Distributions become a paperwork project.

Consolidating doesn’t mean putting everything in one basket. It means giving yourself, or someone you trust, a way to actually see the whole thing.

The Individual Stocks You Don’t Realize You Already Own

Pull up your holdings. Index funds. Target-date funds. That basket of individual tech stocks you’ve held for years. Maybe some company stock from an old employer.

Now look at how much of all that is sitting in the same handful of mega-cap names.

Here’s something worth knowing about index concentration. According to S&P Dow Jones Indices, the 10 largest companies in the S&P 500 are tracked as their own separate index, a reflection of how much weight those names carry within the broader benchmark. Their combined share of the S&P 500 has grown notably over the past decade.

If you own an S&P 500 fund, a total market fund, and a basket of those same individual stocks, you may not be as diversified across them as the account count suggests.

On top of that, individual stocks come with monitoring work:

  • Earnings reports
  • News cycles
  • Tax-lot decisions

When a small number of names drive a large share of your gains, they can drive a large share of your losses too. For someone within a few years of retirement, that kind of concentration is worth understanding before it becomes a problem.

Funds That Stopped Doing What You Bought Them For

There’s a version of “hands-off” investing that works beautifully. You picked good funds, you didn’t panic, and you let compounding do its job.

Then there’s the version where “hands-off” became “forgot about it.”

Mutual funds and ETFs change. Managers leave. Strategies drift.

A fund you bought in 2012 because of one specific approach may be a considerably different animal today. The ticker is the same. The performance, the risk profile, and even the philosophy may not be.

This isn’t about chasing the hottest fund. Short-term underperformance is normal.

What’s worth a look is the fund that:

  • Has underperformed for years
  • Has had multiple manager changes
  • Is still sitting in your portfolio because no one ever pulled it up

A periodic review isn’t market timing. It’s just making sure your holdings still match the reasons you bought them.

A Portfolio Built for the Climb, Not the Descent

If stocks have been good to you for 30 years, here’s an uncomfortable question.

Is your portfolio still built for someone who’s accumulating, or for someone who’s about to start spending?

Those are two different jobs.

Accumulating means time is on your side. You can ride out downturns. You may even welcome them. The portfolio’s only job is to grow.

Spending is the opposite.

Now you’re pulling money out, and the order of returns starts to matter. A bad market in your first few years of retirement can do real damage that a bull market ten years later won’t undo.

That’s sequence of returns risk, and it’s why the same allocation that built your wealth may not be the right one to live on.

The fix isn’t to abandon growth. You’ll likely need stocks to keep up with inflation for decades.

One way to address this risk is by holding a portion of the portfolio in more conservative assets, which may help reduce the likelihood of having to sell stocks during a downturn to cover expenses.

Organizing the portfolio around what you actually need, and when, can reduce some of the guesswork in bear markets.

The trade-off is real:

  • Holding more conservative assets can slow long-term growth
  • Holding too little can increase sequence risk during retirement

The right balance depends on your timeline, income sources, and spending needs.

The hard part is emotional. Shifting toward a more conservative allocation feels like leaving money on the table, especially after a strong run.

That’s exactly why it tends to get put off until something forces the conversation.

The Right Investments in the Wrong Accounts

This one is easy to overlook on your own, and it can quietly cost you real money.

It’s called asset location, and it’s different from asset allocation.

  • Allocation is what you own
  • Location is which type of account you hold it in

Here’s why it matters.

Different investments are taxed differently. Bond interest is taxed as ordinary income. Long-term capital gains and qualified dividends get more favorable treatment.

Roth accounts grow tax-free. Traditional IRAs and 401(k)s grow tax-deferred. Taxable brokerage accounts get taxed along the way.

The general principle is to match the investment to the account that treats it best.

Tax-inefficient holdings, like high-yield bonds and REITs, often belong in tax-deferred or Roth accounts. Tax-efficient holdings, like broad-market stock index funds and municipal bonds, often work better in taxable accounts.

In retirement, you may have more flexibility over your taxes than at other points in your life. Asset location is one of the levers available, and it can be overlooked in planning conversations.

When asset location is off, you might be leaving tax savings on the table over the years.

The fix isn’t always immediate. Selling appreciated positions in a taxable account can trigger its own tax bill, so repositioning has to be planned carefully.

Whether the long-term benefit justifies the cost depends on your account types, tax bracket, and time horizon. A qualified tax professional can help evaluate the trade-offs.

The Bottom Line

None of these issues are dramatic. That’s why they last so long.

A portfolio can look fine on the surface while quietly being:

  • More scattered
  • More concentrated
  • Less current
  • Less aligned
  • Less tax-efficient

The fix isn’t to overhaul everything at once.

It’s to take an honest look at the whole picture, ideally with someone who isn’t emotionally attached to how it got built.

Small adjustments, made on purpose, tend to compound just like the markets do.

Got questions, comments, or feedback? Simply hit reply! We personally read and respond to every message.

Thanks for being a part of MY Wealth Watch!

Keeping wealth in focus,

The MY Wealth Management Team

Do You Need Professional Retirement Planning Help? Find out how to maximize retirement success while cutting tax costs:
Free Retirement Evaluation →

MY Wealth Management, Inc. is a Registered Investment Adviser. This newsletter is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where MY Wealth Management, Inc. and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. No advice may be rendered by MY Wealth Management, Inc. unless a client service agreement is in place.

All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Commentary reflects the personal views and analyses of MY Wealth Management, Inc. employees at the time of publication and should not be considered a description of advisory services or client performance.

Information provided herein should not be relied upon as the sole basis for making financial decisions. Readers should consult with their professional adviser regarding their individual situation before making any financial, tax, or legal decisions.


Whether you're a few years from retirement or already in it, our newsletter is built for people 50+ who want to make the most of their next chapter. Twice a month, we share financial strategies, market insights, and practical tips to help you grow and protect your wealth.


Read next ...