Take a look at your investment statement.

Not the account balance. Look at the list of investments underneath it.

Now pick one and ask yourself three questions:

What is this for? When will I use it? How does it help fund my retirement?

If you cannot answer those questions for every investment, you are not alone.

Many portfolios are not intentionally designed. They are accumulated over time.

And that can become a problem when retirement gets closer.

Nobody Plans to Build a Complicated Portfolio

Think back over the last 20 or 30 years.

Maybe you bought a stock because a coworker would not stop talking about it. Maybe you left an old 401(k) behind when you changed jobs. Maybe you added a mutual fund because it had a great track record. Maybe your employer stock became a much larger part of your portfolio than you ever intended.

None of those decisions had to be bad decisions.

They simply happened at different points in your life.

When you were working, you had a paycheck coming in every two weeks. You had years to recover from a bad investment decision. Your portfolio’s job was mostly to grow.

Then retirement gets closer, and that collection of investments takes on a new responsibility. It has to help provide your paycheck, possibly for 20, 30 years or more.

That changes the way you should look at what you own.

We Are Good at Adding. We Are Not as Good at Taking Away.

Researchers at the University of Virginia published a study in Nature showing that when people are asked to improve something, they tend to overlook the option of removing elements and default to adding instead.

Add another feature. Add another investment. Add another strategy.

That is one reason portfolios can become more complicated over time.

Nobody sits down and says, “I want 27 different investments.”

Instead, it happens one decision at a time. Before long, you have a portfolio that tells the story of your financial history, but not necessarily a portfolio designed for the next chapter.

What Can Hide Inside a Complicated Portfolio?

When we review portfolios that have accumulated over many years, a few issues come up more than others.

You may own the same thing more than you realize.

Two or three funds can have very different names while owning many of the same companies. On paper, the portfolio looks diversified. In reality, several investments may move together when markets fall.

One company may have become too important.

This often happens with employer stock. If you worked for a successful company for many years, that stock may have grown into a sizable portion of your wealth.

But there is an important question to ask: How much of your retirement should depend on the same company that once provided your paycheck?

Your investments may not be in the right accounts.

The investment itself is only part of the equation. Where you hold it can affect the taxes you pay now and in retirement. Your taxable accounts, traditional retirement accounts, and Roth accounts can each serve a different purpose.

You may not have a plan for where withdrawals come from.

This is especially important once retirement begins.

If your portfolio drops sharply and you need to sell investments to cover your living expenses, you may be forced to sell after a decline. Two things to consider. Keeping cash on hand outside the portfolio for near-term needs, and holding cash inside the portfolio when you are taking regular withdrawals. Neither protects against loss, and neither guarantees that a portfolio will recover.

There may be no clear order for what gets sold.

You may know what you own, but do you know what you would sell first?

What about second?

And what would determine when you make that decision?

Those questions become much more important when your portfolio starts replacing your paycheck.

Retirement-Ready Means Every Dollar Has a Job

A retirement-ready portfolio does not need to be complicated.

In fact, it should be easier to explain.

You should be able to look at your investments and understand what each part is designed to do.

That does not mean dividing your money into separate pockets for separate goals. It means the portfolio as a whole is built and diversified around what you actually need it to do, and every holding in it earns its place.

Some investments are there for long-term growth. Some are there because they behave differently when markets move. And when a client is drawing monthly income, we will hold cash within the portfolio so those withdrawals do not have to come out of investments at a bad time.

The important part is that each dollar has a purpose you can name.

Four Questions to Ask About Every Investment

Pull up your statement and look at each holding.

Then ask:

1. What does this investment do that I do not already own?

If two investments serve nearly the same purpose, owning both may not provide as much diversification as you think.

2. When would I use this money?

Money you may need in the next few years should generally be treated differently than money you will not need for decades.

3. What am I really paying?

Look beyond the headline expense ratio. Consider fund expenses, advisory fees, trading costs, and any other costs associated with managing the investment.

4. Could I explain why I own this to someone else?

If you cannot explain the purpose of an investment in a sentence or two, it may be worth taking a closer look.

Failing one of these questions does not automatically make an investment bad.

It simply means the investment deserves another look.

Cleaning Things Up Can Have a Cost

There is one important caveat.

Simplifying a portfolio is not always as easy as selling everything you do not like.

If an investment is held in a taxable account and has appreciated significantly, selling it could create a large capital gains tax bill.

That does not mean you should ignore the problem.

It means the cleanup needs to be planned.

Sometimes the best approach is to make changes over several years, use tax-loss harvesting where it applies, or coordinate investment changes with a broader tax strategy. Each of these has limits and depends on your account types and tax situation.

The goal is not to make the portfolio look cleaner.

The goal is to make it work better.

One Last Thought

Take another look at that investment statement.

Could your spouse understand it if you were not there to explain it?

Could you explain the purpose of every investment five years from now?

Could your family understand what to do if something happened to you?

A complicated portfolio creates more than investment decisions. It creates more decisions for the people you love.

Simple does not mean unsophisticated.

That is the difference between a collection of investments and a retirement plan.

Have any questions, comments, or feedback? Just hit reply! We personally go through and answer each message.
​
Thanks for reading!
​
​Keeping wealth in focus,

The MY Wealth Management Team